Help Me Decide

Thought I’d start a general advice thread for those times you probably already know the answer to your question, but need some encouragement or a voice of reason. Can be music related or not.

My first conundrum - I’m currently turning over my record collection so I can afford some new music. I collected Moodymann albums and 12"s like crazy back in the day and have around 20 releases, none of which I have played in any capacity for a long time. Do I set them free and make a bit of coin, or do I hang on to them, knowing it’s unlikely I’ll ever buy or own them again and may regret my decision?

1 Like

Keep Shades of Jae, sell the rest.

1 Like

keep the albums, sell the 12"s (except for shades of jae and joy pt. II)

This thread is working already! haha

And the ‘thief that stole my sad days’. keep that.

1 Like

Oh and Black Mahogany. I’d keep that.

As a counterpoint, I’d sell them all. That music is super popular right now AND some new fans will be thrilled to own a piece of this history. If you’re not playing them and they’re sought after, why hoard them for a better moment? Those are all available digitally when you want to revisit them.

3 Likes

I should mention that I’ve been selling incredibly sentimental records recently which has been difficult. Limited releases, test pressings, rare stuff. But I rarely (if ever) bring it to a gig so what value does it have on my shelves? Someone chomping at the bit for a copy will enjoy the ownership more than you will.

2 Likes

you beat me to it - I couldn’t let those two go! haha

1 Like

The fact that I don’t gig any more makes it easier for me to part with the dancefloor end of my collection and focus on my “old man listening to music at home” tunes.

edit - uploaded a bunch of MM plus Andres and Theo Parrish releases.

1 Like

Rip them and sell. Although, after a few house moves in recent years, I have become pretty unsentimental about getting shot of the majority of my records (and books).